Scleroderma Study Results Comes As Bitter Disappointment PDF Print E-mail
Monday, 25 January 2010 12:39
taken from http://www.flickr.com/photos/29498542@N05/3183183488/ via creative commonsElizabeth Lombard has Scleroderma.

The disease, which has no cure, has long confounded South Boston, where a cluster of longtime residents from the City Point section - most of them middle-aged women - were falling ill with it. The residents, who lived near a power plant and hazardous waste sites, believed they were victims of their environment.

Their case gained national media attention and sparked an 11-year investigation by the Massachusetts Department of Public Health. In their findings, released earlier this month, state researchers acknowledged “higher than expected cases’’ of Scleroderma in South Boston, a neighborhood of roughly 30,000 people.

But it determined that genetics, not the environment, played a significant role.

“It’s not necessarily that the community they were living in was producing this disease,’’ said Robert Simms, the chief of rheumatology at Boston Medical Center and a researcher in the study. “When you look at the data, it does not support that.’’

Researchers also said low participation in the $1.75 million study may have limited their ability to find an environmental link.

Without a large enough sample, Simms said, it was difficult for scientists to gather reliable estimates on Scleroderma’s link to the residents’ proximity to toxic wastes and other pollutants.

“Those are the things the South Boston study tried to do and came up short,’’ said Simms, who added that the study now opens the door for much larger, national research.

The study found that people with a family history of specific autoimmune-rheumatic diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis, Raynaud’s disease, lupus, and thyroid disease, were more likely to develop Scleroderma.

For the women afflicted with the disfiguring disease, the findings have come as a bitter disappointment.

“I thought that if we had an answer then we could fix it,’’ said Lombard, whose eyebrows have fallen out and whose face is tight and covered with red blotches. “It would help us make sense of why so many of my neighbors have this horrible disease.’’

In the study, researchers collected information about participants’ residential, occupational, and family medical histories. They checked for possible exposures to pollution, including hazardous waste sites and a Coastal Oil refinery.

Researchers tried to recruit large numbers of people for the study, but ended up with 41 people who have the disease and 219 randomly selected individuals who did not have it.

Such a small sample, though it suggested no link to the environment, was not large enough to draw hard conclusions, Simms said.

“The trouble is that science isn’t perfect,’’ said Simms. “It can’t always give the emotional validation that they are seeking.’’

For a link to the full story, click here.
 
More articles :

» Top 10 Scleroderma Stories For 2012

For the hundreds of thousands of people around the world, living with Scleroderma can be particularly challenging. As part of the Foundation's ongoing mission, we seek to source and provide useful information, tips, and articles which can help...

» Aspirin, Simvastatin Not Effective for Pulmonary Arterial Hypertension

Neither aspirin nor simvastatin improved outcomes for patients with in a phase II safety and efficacy trial recently published online in and simultaneously presented at the annual meeting of the .The primary end point of 6-minute walk distance did...

» Thank You

The Scleroderma Care Foundation launched its one month ago on September 1st, and we did so with several aims in mind. Firstly we sought to provide patients, their families, and friends with relevant and timely information on Scleroderma, tips for...

» Testing New Drugs for Early Diffuse Systemic Sclerosis

For patients with the connective tissue disease known as Systemic Sclerosis or – there are few reliable drug treatments. There has been emerging interest in the potential of a class of drugs called (TKI) to ameliorate a major feature of the...

» Chinese Medicine Used In The Treatment Of Scleroderma

According to many proponents of eastern medicine, Chinese medicine is a whole holistic system that can lead to a healthier, happier and more stress free way of living. It is a system that people have benefited from for over twenty-three centuries...

» A Scleroderma Fact Sheet

Below, is a very useful fact sheet on Scleroderma. Making for much easier reading and reference, this fact sheet highlights what Scleroderma is, how is it diagnosed, who gets it, complications which may arise, and how it can be treated. Feel free to...